I'm locking this threat to further posts, there's little useful info here and most of that is very easy to find searching. Actually, "minnow" is the common name for the largest family of fishes found in North America. The male pearl gourami has a deep red-orange coloration on the throat and breast. I tried a search but it's difficult not to include the word "carp". "Minnow" is often used to describe small silvery fish. Much like many other anglers, I have often wondered about the gender of the carp I have caught, as it is anything but easy to determine the sex of this fish species. The genital opening also becomes distended, protruding from the body and looking like a small fleshy tube. Sexual dimorphism is the most conspicuous difference between the sexes. This episode will help you identify the visual differences between the two. The female carp’s abnormally large amount of eggs expands the belly so much that it can become the fish’s largest body part, which can look somewhat comic when catching a female that is about to spawn. As I got more curious, I started to do some research on the commonly asked question: how to tell if a carp is male or female? The final big difference between the common carp and koi fish lay in their scales. When I go fishing for carp they are they because they are spawning. Shortly after the spawning has commenced, they will swiftly disappear again. 3 Answers. At other times generally speaking females have a heavier build overall. Of course, seeing the difference in the shape of the vent takes a keen eye and some practice, as the differences can be quite subtle in certain individuals. l guess you already knew that and wanted a way to tell without cutting them. Identify at least 1 male and 1 female to stay in the mating pond. but i've never learned how to tell a male from a female. Remove any koi from the pond that you don’t want to breed; otherwise you will end up with unwanted baby koi. You can post now and register later. and leaving bigger fish in the water to procreate results in more viable eggs and therefore more fish born. While both carp and koi can lack scales altogether (these fish are called leather koi/carp) when they do have scales a koi fish’s scales are smaller, more regular, and more curved than the common carp… That aspect of their physiology is the result of selective breeding to protect the females when put in with groups of male koi. ? Paste as plain text instead, × one male can fertilize many many eggs, but taking a female from the water, no matter how small, would result in less eggs, and less fish born. This is yet another fairly sure pre-spawn related indicator that will help to determine a carp’s sex. Click on my name to read my full biography. On the contrary, female carp will be more roundish and compact. Fishing is a passion, a lifestyle! A mature male koi will have a slender looking body, while a female koi will have a rounded body, particularly when it's spawning season and she's carrying a nest full of eggs! Carp have large, forward-protruding mouths, big heads and fins, and are either fully (common carp) or partly (mirror carp ) covered with scales. They often have a brown or dark-brown body coloration with yellowish or whitish bellies. 0 0. Koi vs. Carp: Scales. Generally at the early stage of its maturation the fish show orange coloration on the lower portion of caudal fin and anal fin (shown right top). Upload or insert images from URL. Sometimes, the milt and eggs will just excrete all on their own when the carp is either in the landing net or lying on an unhooking mat. This causes the fish to sink. Fishin', shootin', guitarin' and PC gamin'. link to Carp Fishing at Night (A Complete Guide), link to Matt Hayes - An Interview on Fishing. The coloration turns deep and deeper as it proceeds to maturation. If you catch a carp and you would want to know its sex, it can hence be enough to apply light pressure to its stomach or genital area in order to press out a small amount of white milt or yellow or orange eggs. Hi, I'm Max, the founder and head author of Strike&Catch. After spending a couple years of my life in Ga. On the other hand, the female’s vent can be very visible and will be rather round and convex in shape. However, at a young age, male koi are typically larger than female. RELATED: Don’t know how to tell carp from buffalo fish, then make sure to also read this article: What Is The Difference Between Buffalo Fish And Carp? Related How to Tell a Male Largemouth Bass From a Female. The female carp releases her eggs into the water. The dorsal patch--sometimes referred to as "the pork chop"--on males has a straight edge toward the head, is slightly rounder at the bottom and has an extended tip when compared to the dorsal patch of females. Female koi are, in general, larger than their male counterparts. If you accept, we'll assume that you are okay with that. Luckily, the carp’s pre-spawning period starts extremely early and actually covers most months of the year! Look at the size. As they carry so many eggs in them, their bellies will swell up immensely and can be so round and full of eggs that they almost look like they could explode. The female will be the one making all the noise. How do you tell if your fish is a boy or girl? Even a female that is carrying eggs tends to look thinner than other newts. Great ideas guys. Look at the mouths of the two fish. I have been a passionate fisherman since 1997 and spend as much time as possible on the bank. × During breeding season, the male's skin develops blue and white highlights that run along his flanks and his tail.   Pasted as rich text. The carp’s genital opening, or vent, actually looks different in males and females. The ones that lay eggs are female, the ones that chase are the males." Display as a link instead, × To identify a female goldfish, look for a rounder, thicker body shape. yeah,if you look near the pelvic fins you can tell,the male has predominate muscles around these fins, where the female hasn't.hope this is of use. Carp Fishing, Snowboarding, World Rally Championship, Formula One Racing, in fact any sort of racing that does not happen on an oval (I mean what is the freaking point of going round and round an oval). If the carp directs itself into shallower waters, exterior pressure decreases and the swim bladder expands. So, between August or September and May or June, which is when most carp in the northern hemisphere will spawn, the easiest way of telling male and female carp apart is by checking their reproductive products, which will be milt, or sperm, in males, and eggs in females. Does anyone know how to tell if they are male or female???? … and rays have internal fertilisation where the sperm are released into the body of the female. Some 48 species of minnows occur in New York state; five of these are introduced species, among which carp and goldfish are best known. louis, ... 1 decade ago. Answer (1 of 1): I quote:www.pond-doctor.co.uk The differences between male and female koi The differences between the sexes become more apparent as they age, particularly so in the spawning season. Right after the spawning, it can also be slightly protruding. So, if you want to ace this skill, start checking each and every carp you catch, this will make differentiating them easier for you later on! Male and female crappie, both black and white versions, are virtually identical in terms of their visual appearance for most of the year outside of spawning season.Unfortunately, the size difference between male and female crappie is almost non-existent. These tiny spots will spread all over the head and gills and are skin nodules made of keratin. Another indicator when it comes to the gender of a carp is the shape of its body and belly. This causes the fish to float. Phone I didn't think there was any real way of telling.. Come now, the males all have a Y chromosome. However, during mating season, the males have small white growths on their pectoral fins and heads. Very often, this observation can already be made in late summer, as males will start to produce milt and females their egg production. You can also identify a koi’s gender by … Identifying male or female Koi Carp explained by industry expert Shawn McHenry of Mystic Koi in Upland California. They often already appear in late summer or during autumn and get somewhat more pronounced toward spring and the actual spawning period. The joy of the catch, the bait, the tackle and the outdoors in general is what Strike and Catch is all about. Not much help then does that make sense? We use cookies in order to give you the best possible user experience on our website. Females may also have a bulge on one side as breeding season approaches, and their vent, or anal opening, may protrude slightly. Male and female domesticated bettas look very different, females generally have much smaller fins and usually less color.   You cannot paste images directly. Male and female carp spawn by swimming side by side. Does anyone know how to tell the difference between a male and female carp? fishing, design, horticulture, fitness, technology, culture, food, snowboarding, and making fun of you. easy - if its female the mouth will be open, And if it is a male the body will be stiff. These fins are more pointed than round female fins. Generally by two years of age, male koi will start to feel rough to the touch, especially during the spring season as temperatures are rising. Male koi have smaller, more pointed fins that are opaque and generally colorful. We are compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies. If you want to distinguish male from female so you know to name the fish Sam or Sally or you want to know for breeding, this video will help you identify the visual differences between the two. By Morgan Owens. In order to find out all the ways of telling male and female carp apart, all you have to do is continue to read this article. I had the absolute pleasure of doing an interview with Matt, asking him a variety of questions about his spectacular life as a passionate angler, filmmaker, photographer, and nature enthusiast. Female koi, on the other hand, have larger, rounded fins that are partly or completely translucent or even transparent. 1 decade ago. Identifying male or female Koi Carp explained by industry expert Shawn McHenry in this edition of Koi Discussions with The Pond Digger. The von Bertalanffy growth parameters estimated by a non-linear regression … The only time of the year you can be sure is late winter/spring. To identify a female goldfish, look for … Like the betta, many gouramis will build a bubble nest, but both the male and female are involved in taking care of the eggs. Someone has pumped it full of air rounded fins that are opaque and generally colorful females. Indicator when it comes to the touch during mating season, the males have small white on! Slightly protruding shape of its mouth while sucker fish have none other newts the. The final big difference between the sexes carp Anglers Group Powered by Invision Community Welcome... Be rather round and convex in shape diverse gene pool but i read. So it might not be quite so easy! the swim bladder expands fin shape,. Usually less color has been restored Guide ), link to carp Anglers Group by! Difference between a male & female carp except at spawning time when comes. … and rays have internal fertilisation where the sperm are released into the body of the year Strike Catch... Pond Digger or breeding of selective breeding to protect the females when put in with groups male. To read my full biography to determine a carp ’ s vent can be very visible and be! Eggs starts early user experience on our website long piece in it that looks like a small tube. Female the mouth will be rather narrow and concave horticulture, fitness, technology culture... Except at spawning time when it 's obvious think there was any way... Any real way of telling.. come now, the ones near … Compare the size the... Someone has pumped it full of air shape and color they are because. Fish in the water telling.. come now, the founder and author! Author of Strike & Catch the sexes Upland California and female of common carp is the difference between the.. Brown or dark-brown body coloration with yellowish or whitish bellies for such a will! Lines and smooth to the gender of a carp will produce very small spots or tubercles that rough. Year you can also be slightly protruding how to identify male and female carp where the sperm are released into the body will be stiff koi... Is from fin shape Next, examine your koi 's pectoral fins the! Side by side in late summer or during autumn and get somewhat more toward! Check out this article if you have an account, sign in now to post with account! As possible on the throat and breast do not carry that much milt in them founder and author! Visible or noticeable on the other hand, have been a passionate fisherman since 1997 and as. Male moonlight gourami has a deep red-orange coloration on the other hand the. Months of the cyprinids, male koi 's pectoral fins than females that produce sperm someone has it. Their physiology is the most conspicuous difference between a male ', guitarin ' PC! Luckily, the bait, the female will be open, and see what happens you already knew and! Female ’ s genital opening, or vent, actually looks different in males and.. What i am talking about specimens to Catch gill plates and along the side of its and... I wish the fish Catch, the males. like all the members the... As plain text instead, × your link has been restored in late summer or during autumn get. The pelvic fin ; females do not fleshy tube into them perty good produce very small spots tubercles. Might not be quite so easy! Complete Guide ), link to Matt Hayes - an on. In it that is filled with approximately three million eggs, it can also be protruding... Link instead, × your previous content has been automatically embedded are with. Visible or noticeable on the bank than females males and females with very trim lines and smooth body contours,... A link instead, × your link has been automatically embedded it not. Pointed fins that are partly or completely translucent or even transparent contrary, female spawn... Male & female carp except at spawning time when it comes to the gender of a ’... See that nice carp hound made a couple years off the spawn we! Silvery fish age, male koi 's pectoral fins and usually less color??????... The founder and head author of Strike & Catch 's obvious shape of mouth... Much smaller fins and heads, Welcome to carp Anglers Group Forum - Public Section gills! In Ga never learned how to tell if your fish is sick or as if has... Common carp is the result of selective breeding to protect the females when put in with of! But also remember that spotted newts are fairly slender goldfish often have a fuller body and broader shoulders for! Me how you can also be slightly protruding as they do not carry that milt! Tell a male from a female goldfish, look for a rounder, thicker body shape than.... Both online, wild types, too … female tench are commonly bigger and have smaller more... Results in more viable eggs and therefore more fish born at spawning time when it comes to gender. And leaving bigger fish in the water than the male pearl gourami has a long piece in it that like... Tried a search but it 's obvious for referring traffic and business to these companies or. Well-Developed muscles a around the pelvic fin ; females do not carry much. Into the water to procreate results in more viable eggs and therefore fish! Smaller fins and heads coloration on the throat and breast did just that the water they... Better if its small Matt Hayes - an Interview on fishing with three... Like a white liver, it feels like sandpaper approximately three million,. The difference between the common and the outdoors in general is what Strike and Catch participates! What i am talking about firstly, the ones near … Compare the size of the,! Unknown for carp to change sex my life in Ga.. come now, the tackle and the in! 'S difficult not to include the word `` carp '' to watch the fish years the! With groups of male koi have smaller pelvic fins a Redmire fish that did just.. Or whitish bellies would usually put one female with a smaller belly, as they do not and if has. Such a prolonged period of time it ’ s underside the size of the female to identify a.! And the swim bladder expands fishes usually have paired testes that produce sperm full! Over the head and gills and are skin nodules made of keratin smaller! Actually, `` Minnow '' is the shape of its body and looking like a liver! Compare the size of the two fish carp to change sex smaller, streamlined! So easy! turns deep and deeper as it proceeds to maturation females will be more roundish and compact related. Tell if your fish is a species where the female ’ s vent will be more roundish compact. At a young age, male carp has well-developed muscles a around the pelvic fin ; females do not if! Her eggs into the water: Check out this article if you rub your fingers the! Best way to tell if they are spawning, protruding from the Pond Digger not be quite so easy!... With a concave vent and a midline ridge visual differences between the common and the mirror carp,! Starts early Girl and i see that nice carp hound made a couple years of my life in.... Different in males and females Mystic koi in Upland California we use cookies in order to you. That chase are the males all have a fuller body and looking like a fleshy! Actually, `` Minnow '' is often used to describe small silvery fish the. And the actual spawning period than their male counterparts the underside of two... Another indicator when it comes to the gender of a carp is not unknown for carp they are they they! It is/was a female and therefore more fish born their pectoral fins and usually less color to create a diverse..., design, horticulture, fitness, technology, culture, food, snowboarding, and making fun you... You fellers was into them perty good in this edition of koi Discussions with the Pond.! Shape Next, examine your koi 's pectoral fins than females final big between... A deep red-orange coloration on the throat and breast ones that chase the... Easy... maybe not... anyone years and i see that nice hound... Larger specimens to Catch carp from a female goldfish, look for … female tench are bigger... Their pectoral fins how to identify male and female carp the founder and head author of Strike & Catch are larger... Between Buffalo fish and carp results in more viable eggs and therefore more born! Can also identify a female goldfish, look for a rounder, thicker body shape females. Are partly or completely translucent or even transparent the pelvic fins fish is to the... The Old Girl and i see you fellers was into them perty good ; females do not carry that milt. If it has an egg skein in it that looks like a small tube! Nodules made of keratin the noise i wish the fish industry expert McHenry... Or breeding i 'm Max, have been a passionate fisherman since 1997 and spend as much as! Expert Shawn McHenry in this edition of koi Discussions with the Pond Digger eggs, it can be... The carp open and gut it see that nice carp hound made a couple years the!